Overall score: B
Recommended? Yes (for the Key Lime pie!)
If you are looking for a great slice of Key Lime pie while in the Florida Keys, definitely check out Sweet Savannah’s located in Marathon. This ice cream shop and bakery is packed full of all different kinds of treats.
The sweet shop sells over 20 different ice cream flavors – including gluten, dairy and sugar-free options (according to their website). The also offer the “Sweet Savannah,” their signature dish, which is a cupcake sundae.
While dining here, we ordered one scoop of cookie dough ice cream and a piece of Key Lime pie. The ice cream seemed fresh, but was light on the cream flavor and was extremely lacking in cookie dough – a little disappointing. The Key Lime pie, however, was very good! With a thick, delicious graham cracker crust, and a sweet (not too tart) filling, this pie was a winner!
So if you are looking for a sweet stop along the Overseas Highway, I’d recommend stopping at Sweet Savannah’s. Be sure to try their delicious Key Lime pie!